A low-profile contemporary home steps down a landscaped coastal hillside beneath a hazy Pacific horizon in Muirlands.

What the Muirlands Rebuilds Tell a Buyer About the Hill

On January 9, 2025, the San Diego Planning Commission spent more than an hour on one house in Muirlands. As the San Diego Union-Tribune reported, the debate covered views, precedent and the role of La Jolla's planning groups before the commission unanimously denied a neighbor's appeal of the project at 812 Havenhurst Point. The plan was to demolish a house of about 3,700 square feet and build a 9,394-square-foot, two-story home.

That hearing is a useful way to read Muirlands as a buyer. Portal medians treat the house as the product. The rebuild proposals heard in public between January 2025 and August 2026 point somewhere else. On this hill, an older house is increasingly priced as the first draft of a bigger one. What limits the bigger one is how tall it stands, how much of it shows, and whose view it touches. Those questions are settled in neighborhood committees and public hearings, and they set the real value of a lot more than the floor plan already standing on it.

The Size of What Replaces a Muirlands House

The four Muirlands-area demolition-and-rebuild proposals reported by the Union-Tribune's La Jolla coverage from January 2025 through August 2026 start from houses of similar size. They end up very different.

Address Existing house Proposed Extras in the plan Outcome reported
812 Havenhurst Point About 3,700 sq ft 9,394 sq ft total Basement, ADU, junior ADU, garage, 3,651 sq ft of decks Appeal denied Jan. 9, 2025
6136 La Jolla Mesa Drive 3,881 sq ft 8,266 sq ft, two stories Three-car garage, pool, spa DPR support Apr. 15, 2025
6555 El Camino del Teatro 2,691 sq ft 4,495 sq ft over a basement Subterranean parking, 1,067 sq ft garage, 639 sq ft ADU DPR support Dec. 9, 2025
5875 Box Canyon Road About 4,200 sq ft, two stories 4,853 sq ft, two stories 1,185 sq ft ADU, front pool, 1,328 sq ft four-stall garage DPR recommended approval Aug. 18, 2026

Every existing house in that table falls between roughly 2,700 and 4,200 square feet. That range covers much of what comes to market on the hill in original or lightly updated condition. Every replacement is larger. Two of the plans more than double the floor area: La Jolla Mesa Drive goes from 3,881 to 8,266 square feet, and Havenhurst Point from about 3,700 to 9,394.

The two smaller rebuilds still add more than their headline numbers suggest. At El Camino del Teatro the house grows by about two-thirds, and the plan adds a detached ADU and a garage larger than many condos. At Box Canyon Road the main house grows by only about 650 square feet. The plan also adds an 1,185-square-foot ADU, a pool and a four-stall garage, so the property ends up carrying much more building than the main-house figure implies.

For a buyer comparing an older Muirlands house to a newer one elsewhere in La Jolla, this is the useful number. The house a Muirlands lot can support, once it clears review, is often much bigger than the one on it today. That gap is the true spread between an original house and a rebuilt one here, and it explains why an older house on a strong lot rarely trades like an older house.

The Extras Have Become Part of the Plan

Basements, ADUs, pools and oversized garages appear across these proposals. Three of the four rebuild plans include an ADU. Havenhurst Point has both an ADU and a junior ADU. Separately, at 5710 La Jolla Mesa Drive, architect Claude Anthony Marengo brought a 1,170-square-foot ADU for an existing house to the La Jolla Development Permit Review committee in April 2025. The committee approved it without questions.

Basements are the other pattern, and they matter on a hillside. The El Camino del Teatro design by Roger Sammon of Island Architects puts the new house over a basement with subterranean parking. Havenhurst Point includes a 1,648-square-foot basement level. A Muirlands Point committee member, Andrew Micheletti, told the Planning Commission that because the house "digs down" into the hillside, it is in effect three stories instead of two, according to the Union-Tribune's account.

On a sloped Muirlands lot, then, the square footage that matters is partly underground. A buyer weighing an older house should look at how the lot falls away from the street as closely as at the rooms already built, because the slope shapes how much house a future plan can tuck below grade.

Height and Views Are Where the Questions Come Up

The size of a Muirlands rebuild is rarely what stops it. The reviews turn on height, bulk and views.

At El Camino del Teatro, the Development Permit Review committee asked for more information in November 2025, and the house's overall height of about 36 feet drew the most questions, according to the Union-Tribune. The committee went on to support the project unanimously on December 9.

At Box Canyon Road, applicant representative Sam Koob said neighbor feedback led the team to remove a proposed chimney and lower the height, according to the Union-Tribune. Some of the original building also survives. The team first planned to keep half the existing house, but Koob said that "wasn't really doable." The existing driveway and some retaining walls will remain, and the new house will be built around them.

Havenhurst Point shows the most about how views are weighed. That section of the hill has the Muirlands Point committee, elected by its 59 lot owners to review construction there. It opposed the plan several times because of its size and its potential to block private views. Neighbors argued the area is mostly one-story houses. Attorney Matt Peterson, for the applicant, answered that "eighty homes in a quarter-mile radius are two stories or taller."

The house was approved over that opposition. For a buyer, the outcome cuts two ways. A view you buy on this hill has neighbors and committees who care about it a great deal, and those same neighbors may one day be reviewing your plans.

The Calendar a Rebuild Runs On

The public record also shows how long these projects take. Havenhurst Point first came before the La Jolla DPR committee and the La Jolla Community Planning Association in spring 2023, at 12,979 square feet, and both voted to oppose it. A city hearing officer approved a revised version in September 2024. The Planning Commission's denial of the appeal came in January 2025. That is close to two years of public review for one house, and the design that came out was about 3,600 square feet smaller than the one that went in.

Smaller rebuilds have moved faster. El Camino del Teatro went from a request for more information on November 18, 2025 to unanimous support three weeks later. Box Canyon Road was asked to come back after its August 11, 2026 review. A week later it returned with the landscape plan and the paving and footpath designs that trustee Angeles Leira had requested, and it left with a unanimous recommendation for approval.

Plants and trees come up in review too. At 6136 La Jolla Mesa Drive, applicant representative Tim Martin wanted to keep eucalyptus trees he called "community character-defining," the Union-Tribune reported. The DPR committee supported his request that the city waive its sidewalk requirement and accept a curb-and-gutter alternative.

The pattern across these projects is consistent. A rebuild that grows modestly, answers neighbors on height and arrives with landscape detail moves through local review in weeks. A rebuild that roughly triples a house's footprint on a view-sensitive street can take years.

What This Means for an Offer on an Older House

Buying an older Muirlands house is a choice among three plans: keep it, renovate it, or rebuild. Each one prices the lot differently.

If you plan to keep the house, you are paying for a lot whose ceiling is set by what neighbors have proposed and built nearby. That makes the current pipeline a guide to what may rise next door. A two-story replacement near a one-story house is the change the Havenhurst Point neighbors were contesting, and it is the scenario a view buyer should test before writing an offer.

If you plan to renovate, Box Canyon Road is a fair warning. Its team set out to keep half of an existing two-story house and decided it could not. The bones of an older Muirlands house do not always support the house a buyer has in mind, and whether they do is a question for an architect and a builder before the inspection period ends.

If you plan to rebuild, the recent projects suggest a range for the outcome. Expect a larger two-story house on a lot that once held 2,700 to 4,200 square feet, likely with an ADU, often with a basement and a pool, and a long conversation with neighbors about height and views. On this hill, the choice of architect matters about as much as the purchase price. The Havenhurst applicant told the Planning Commission her family had chosen an architect experienced with La Jolla's neighborhood committees and attentive to views.

Our buyer resources cover how we line up those conversations before an offer. Owners on the hill who want to know how a buyer would price their lot can start with a home valuation.

A Few Questions Buyers Ask About Muirlands Rebuilds

Do Muirlands rebuilds always add an ADU? Not always, but three of the four demolition-and-rebuild plans reported from January 2025 through August 2026 include one. Havenhurst Point includes both an ADU and a junior ADU.

Is the neighborhood mostly one-story or two-story? That question was argued directly at the Havenhurst Point hearing. Neighbors described their area as mostly one-story, and the applicant's attorney counted 80 homes two stories or taller within a quarter mile. The answer changes from street to street, and checking the street matters before buying a view.

If you are weighing an original house here against a finished one elsewhere in La Jolla, The Comiskey Group can walk the property with you and the right architect and help you price both the house you would buy and the one you might build.

Marilyn Comiskey seated on a marble kitchen island beside a white orchid arrangement.

Marilyn Comiskey

About Marilyn Comiskey

Marilyn Comiskey is genuinely committed to serving each client with first-class service, true advocacy, and full-service resources that markedly result in each client’s real estate dreams coming true! Featured on HGTV’s The American Dream TV series and ranked within the Top 0.1% of agents nationwide by the Wall Street Journal*, her trusted perspective, acute discretion, and professional representation is highly valued. With over $400 million in transactional sales, she offers a commanding perspective and the insider information her clients need to carefully select their new address. As a specialist in the acquisition and marketing of residential, luxury, off-market, golf course communities, and investment properties, Marilyn excels at serving her clients’ vision across all price points while delivering her proficient counsel with a truly heightened and luxurious real estate experience.

Through her careful analysis and astute and accurate assessment, Marilyn takes great care to advise her clients with an informed and comprehensive understanding of the current real estate market. As a result of representing some of the leading developers and investors in San Diego County and earning the exclusive representation on multiple, large-scale luxury developments, Marilyn is in the know and is highly connected with off-market properties and investment opportunities. She is infectiously passionate about real estate and is known for her vivacious spirit and added panache in her efforts to achieve her client’s goals.

Work With Us

The Comiskey Group’s vast experience and advocacy make for an unstoppable partnership in any real estate transaction, not only for the luxury market. Partner with a team with unwavering dedication, expert negotiation skills and who is determined to assist you in accomplishing your buying and selling goals. We provide a free consultation for buying, selling, renting, or investing in San Diego.

Follow Marilyn on Instagram